How to read versions of a Kubrick screenplay

Not all texts called screenplays describe the same stage. Some set out what will be filmed; others revise a proposal or record dialogue that is already part of a film in preparation for circulation.

Identifying the document before comparing its words

Reading screenplay versions means starting with their material identity. The film’s title is not enough: you need the date, provenance, stated authorship and relationship to other documents. Two copies may contain the same text but have different annotations. A bound version is not necessarily the latest, and a loose sheet may belong to a localised revision rather than a complete screenplay.

The Kubrick archive catalogue entry SK/10/1/21 describes a screenplay for Lolita dated 10 May 1960 and attributed to Vladimir Nabokov. It distinguishes between a bound copy and an unbound copy with deletions. This is a description of the materials, not a transcription of their differences. It allows us to say that physical variants exist; it does not allow us to reconstruct the content of the deletions without examining the pages.

The example shows why the word complete needs context. A text may be complete as a writing proposal and yet not match the finished film. The integrity of the document does not mean that all its scenes were shot or that they retained the same position. The film adaptation of Lolita needs to be distinguished from the written work so that one version is not treated as the sole measure of fidelity.

The collaboration with screenwriters introduces another note of caution. The final writing credit and the authorship of an annotation do not answer the same question. Someone may be credited for the screenplay without having written every change visible in a copy. Conversely, a handwritten intervention does not prove that the person who made it was solely responsible for the entire scene.

Partial revisions and pages that should not be assembled arbitrarily

Another Lolita catalogue entry, SK/10/1/8, lists typescript inserts, probably prepared during production, with changes in Kubrick’s hand on some pages. The word probably reflects the limits of the description and should be retained. Replacing it with an exact filming date would add a certainty that the catalogue entry does not offer.

These inserts raise a different issue from that of a complete draft. To establish their function, it would be necessary to determine which pages they replace, whether they alter numbering or continuity, and which copy they should be linked to. It is not correct to attach any loose fragment to any screenplay for the same film and present the result as a historical version that actually circulated among the participants.

Nor can the sequence of revision be inferred from the number of corrections alone. A clean copy may postdate an annotated one because it incorporates its changes; it may also be a parallel copy intended for another purpose. The text, dates and provenance need to be compared. A more finished appearance does not, by itself, establish a chronology.

The written development of A.I. is a reminder that a project can pass through different writers and stages before its final realisation. Comparing proposals requires those attributions to be kept distinct, rather than constructing a supposed single directorial intention from fragments produced at different times. The continuity of the project’s name does not erase the differences between its materials.

The archival description helps locate these distinctions, but it has its limits. A catalogue entry may group several items without detailing every change. The analysis should indicate when it relies on the catalogue and when on direct examination of the original. Claiming that a particular person crossed out a phrase requires more specific evidence than the mere presence of their name in the collection.

A text produced after filming is not a promise of what was going to be filmed

Eyes Wide Shut offers an example of documentation classified as post-production material: series SK/17/4/4 includes annotated transcripts for editing, dialogue timing records, and a combined list of dialogue, continuity and subtitles. The catalogue entry describes tools related to material that had already been worked on. They should not automatically be read as instructions that preceded the filming of each scene.

The direction of time matters. A preparation screenplay can help us ask what had been planned; a transcript can help identify what was said in a working version. The fact that both contain similar words does not prove that they are interchangeable. To study a change, we need to know whether we are comparing a proposal with a result, or two later records of different results.

The continuity and shot identification documents can establish connections, but they do not justify bypassing the film. A written line may not have been performed, may have been filmed in several ways, or may have been left out of the edit. The correspondence must be checked against identified scenes and versions, without treating the absence of a line as automatic proof of a reason for removing it.

It is also necessary to distinguish dialogue from staging. A film can retain the words while changing their effect through pauses, framing, performance or sound. Textual comparison detects certain differences, but it does not exhaust the film adaptation of a screenplay. An analysis that only lists added and deleted lines overlooks decisions that transform the same conversation without changing its verbal content.

The discarded material ultimately calls for precise vocabulary. A written alternative is not a filmed scene, and a filmed scene is not necessarily part of a released cut. Screenplay versions let us trace possibilities and revisions when their relationships are known. They do not, by themselves, provide a complete alternative film or a reliable explanation of every change between the writing and the release.

Sources: Stanley Kubrick Archive, University of the Arts London, SK/10/1/21, Lolita, 10 May 1960; SK/10/1/8, Script inserts, c. 1960; SK/17/4/4, Dialogue and Film Editing, 1998–1999. Analysis of catalogue descriptions, without attributing readings of unconsulted manuscripts.

View all articles in Kubrick’s working method, documents and archive