Costume and reference images for Napoleon

The surviving images of Napoleon belong to different kinds of work: research, design, testing and planning. Reading them as if they were frames from a finished film erases the decisions that were still unresolved.

Historical images and working drawings answer different questions

A period reference can help identify a garment, a pose or a difference in rank. It does not automatically offer a solution for dressing an actor. A preparatory drawing has to select information and make it usable: how the pieces are arranged, what can be recognised from different angles, and which parts of the body are covered. Between historical document and film costume lies a process of translation, not simple reproduction.

Bonhams’ catalogue devoted to the John Mollo Archive reproduces, in lot 5, designs connected with the unrealised Napoleon film. The plate of a soldier from the 10th Regiment of Dragoons shows the same uniform from the front and the back, with the equipment arranged around the body. It is not a narrative scene. Its layout makes it possible to compare surfaces that a single view would conceal, and to see how clothing, straps and weapons relate to one another.

The two views also prevent the drawing’s function from being confused with a character portrait. It does not aim to describe a particular emotion in Napoleon or Josephine. It treats the body as a support for elements that must remain recognisable and coherent when its orientation changes. This information could serve different crafts, although the plate alone does not prove which garments were made or who would ultimately have worn them.

The project research covered a much broader field of references. Here, the focus is on the move towards a specific visual instruction. A historical painting may be of interest for its composition; a front-and-back drawing organises a different kind of knowledge. Calling both materials inspiration without distinguishing their uses makes it harder to understand what problem each document was intended to solve.

The uniform establishes differences before anyone moves

The reproduced plates show that the uniform is not an undifferentiated surface. Hats, collars, sashes and accessories distribute signals across the body. Even without reconstructing the entire military code, we can observe how certain distinctions are concentrated in visible areas. The drawing makes it possible to compare them consistently, whereas a future film image would have introduced distance, movement, lighting and overlapping figures.

Here, colour serves to distinguish. It makes it possible to tell pieces apart and see which areas contrast with others. It is not enough to establish how they would look under a particular light or in an exhibition print. The printed reproduction of the drawing also introduces its own mediation. It would be wrong to treat its hues as a definitive palette for the feature film Kubrick would have made.

The views of the equipment also show a relationship between appearance and use. A strap crosses the torso; a weapon occupies one side; a bag changes the shape of the back. These arrangements affect how a body can be read as part of a group. The analysis does not require us to imagine a movement test that has not been consulted. It is enough to recognise that the design prepares a complete figure, not merely the part that would look most striking in a frontal portrait.

Camera distance would have created different requirements. An accessory that helps to signal rank at close quarters may disappear in a wide shot. This is a production question that helps explain why detail and scale need to be studied together; it is not a claim about any final shots. The preparation for the filming of Napoleon documents the material context in which those questions had to become decisions.

A test provides evidence without completing the film

The same catalogue describes another group of letters and documents that includes photographs of costumes taken at Kubrick’s house. This reference makes it possible to distinguish designs on paper from the existence of certain material tests. It does not justify claiming that all the planned costumes were finished. A test may be intended precisely to reject, adjust or compare a solution before reproducing it on a larger scale.

The difference between designing one piece and approving a series matters in a project involving large groups. The first process explores a solution; the second requires it to be reproduced, adapted for different people and kept consistent. The document consulted does not provide a complete inventory of garments made. The value of the surviving material therefore lies in what it allows us to examine directly, not in imaginatively filling in the missing steps.

The costume in Kubrick’s films can be studied in finished films through the relationships between clothing, gesture and social position. In Napoleon, that final encounter with the performance never took place in the form of a feature film. A designed uniform can anticipate rank and affiliation, but it does not in itself contain an interpretation. Likewise, a reference for a female figure does not determine the dramatic behaviour of Josephine in the screenplay.

Comparison with the costumes in Barry Lyndon must begin with this disparity in the evidence. There, garments are photographed within scenes, bodies move and situations change. Here, there are preparatory materials. Questions of period and hierarchy can be considered in relation to one another, but the two works cannot be assessed as if we had two complete films, nor can we infer that every earlier design was reused.

Looking at these plates as working tools allows us to appreciate specific decisions without inventing a final aesthetic. The body’s orientation, the visibility of accessories and the separation of pieces can be observed. The duration of a shot, the performers’ behaviour and the integration into a sequence cannot. Between these two levels lay the filming that never took place to resolve them, and that distance is part of the images’ documentary significance.

References: Bonhams, Designing an Empire: The John Mollo Archive, catalogue dated 11 December 2018, lots 5 and 6, pages 14–16; reproductions and description of materials. University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, preparation for Napoleon, SK/18/1/1.

View all articles in Kubrick’s Napoleon: the development of an unrealised project