The Napoleon screenplay dated 29 September 1969 can be studied as an identifiable narrative proposal. Its scenes and transitions describe a planned film, not a work that was ever made.
A dated version and a life too long to show in full
The cover of the text consulted identifies Stanley Kubrick as its author and bears the date 29 September 1969. The documentary edition prepared by Alison Castle reproduces that version in facsimile. Identifying it makes it possible to discuss a specific structure without indiscriminately bringing together treatments, notes and later proposals. The project continued to generate ideas, so a reading of the dated text should not be presented as an inventory of every form Kubrick came to consider.
The written account spans childhood, education, rise, exercise of power, defeat and exile. This breadth poses a problem of selection rather than exhaustiveness. No narrative of limited duration can give equal development to every year or event. Choosing which moments become scenes and which are summarised establishes an interpretation of the trajectory. Biographical continuity does not eliminate that selection; it makes it visible through changes in pace and scale.
The historical research for the project provided a much broader context than could fit into a film. Its relationship with the screenplay is not a matter of transferring one entry after another. A scene needs actions, positions and information distributed between characters and viewers. The writing reorganises documentary material according to those needs, and an ellipsis can be as important as a developed episode if it changes what the audience knows when the next scene begins.
The study of the adaptation and transformation of pre-existing material helps to clarify that process. A biography, a letter and a conversation between characters do not offer the same point of view. Turning documentation into action requires decisions about who knows a fact, when they express it and what effect it has on someone else. A screenplay can draw on historical sources and still be a dramatic construction, without thereby becoming a neutral transcription of the past.
Telling a life story and showing someone trying to direct it
The text distinguishes between the narrator’s contributions, words attributed to Napoleon and situations described for the camera. This distribution makes it possible to convey information that the protagonist does not express in an immediate conversation. It also creates the possibility of comparing what someone says about themselves with the context provided by the narration. The explanatory voice should not automatically be confused with the character’s private perspective, or with the director’s personal opinion in every detail.
The planned maps introduce another scale of information. A conversation can make an individual decision perceptible; a spatial representation can relate it to distances, territories and movements that do not fit within a room. The change is not simply decorative. It organises a relationship between close-up experience and historical breadth. Its effectiveness on screen would have depended on duration, design and editing: aspects the document can propose without resolving them as a finished film.
The question of narrators and voice-over is especially useful for reading this alternation. A voice can condense time, introduce context or anticipate a consequence. Each function changes the viewer’s relationship with the scene. Knowing an outcome in advance can shift attention from surprise to how it is reached. Dramatic interest does not necessarily disappear when the ending is known; it can shift to decisions, contradictions and limits of understanding.
The written structure thus invites a comparison between the ability to command and the ability to know. The protagonist can issue orders without controlling all their consequences, and the narrative can offer a broader perspective than that of those acting within an episode. This is a reading of the narrative organisation, not a claim that the screenplay provides a sufficient explanation of every historical process it represents.
Private ties within a public representation of power
The planned sequence of Josephine’s divorce places an intimate decision in a ceremony involving dynastic reasons and public formulae. The contrast makes it possible to examine how a personal relationship becomes a matter of government. Its dramatic interest is not limited to deciding whether a declaration is sincere. The words have to work in front of others and within an institution, while the situation retains consequences for those who shared the relationship.
From this perspective, power and its institutions do not appear only on the battlefield. They also determine who speaks, what justification can be offered and how a decision is presented to those who must accept it. The difference between a personal emotion and a public explanation does not require us to consider every statement false. It allows us to recognise that speaking from a position of authority imposes forms and audiences unlike those of a private conversation.
The final section narrows the character’s field of action and turns attention back to relationships and memories. This narrowing can be read as a contrast with the preceding breadth: changing the conditions of space and exchange transforms the reach of authority. This reading is grounded in the written structure, not in an imagined performance. We do not know the voices, gestures or response times the actors would have brought to those situations during filming.
The screenplay can therefore be analysed in its own right without requiring a critique of a non-existent film. Its selection, its relationship between information and scene, and the tensions it proposes between public and private life can all be studied. It does not allow us to declare how each shot would have worked or what changes Kubrick would have made while filming or editing. The 1969 version preserves specific narrative decisions; recognising its possibilities does not require turning actions that were still written as proposals into audiovisual results.
References: Stanley Kubrick, Napoleon, screenplay dated 29 September 1969, English-language text. Eva-Maria Magel, ‘The Best Movie (N)ever Made: Stanley Kubrick’s Failed Napoleon Project’, Stanley Kubrick exhibition catalogue, pp. 156–159. Rijksmuseum Research Library, bibliographic record for Stanley Kubrick’s Napoleon, edited by Alison Castle, identifying the screenplay facsimile.
View all articles in Kubrick’s Napoleon: the development of an unrealised project
