Napoleon and Josephine in Kubrick’s project

In the Napoleon screenplay, the relationship with Josephine makes it possible to compare public authority with an emotional dependence that authority cannot resolve. This analysis concerns the text dated September 1969, not scenes that were filmed.

Two different experiences within the same relationship

The relationship between Napoleon and Josephine is not reduced in the screenplay to the love story of a ruler. Its dramatic function is to introduce a space where power cannot guarantee reciprocation. Someone who seeks to organise campaigns and public decisions cannot order another person to feel the same way. This difference makes it possible to read intimacy as a difficulty in its own right, rather than as a respite between military events.

The text dated 29 September 1969 uses letters and voices to contrast the characters’ positions. The intensity of Napoleon’s words does not automatically match Josephine’s willingness. The reader receives information that makes it impossible to accept one person’s account as a complete description of the couple. This distribution of perspectives matters more than deciding which of them sums up some supposed thesis about all marriages.

A letter also requires distance. The writer tries to reach someone who is not present and cannot control what will happen when it is read. The screenplay can place that declaration alongside an activity that contradicts its expectations. The intended result is a difference between what the character believes they are sustaining through words and what the reader knows about the situation. It is not yet possible to determine the specific effect that a voice or film edit would have produced.

The structure of the Napoleon screenplay examines the narrative as a whole. Here, the focus is on a more limited operation: the couple do not share a consciousness. Each character acts on their own desires, information and expectations. This asymmetry can produce jealousy, calculation or a misinterpretation of gestures, without requiring every private decision to be explained as a symptom of a historical personality.

Intimacy enters the representation of power

The contrast between campaigns and private life does not establish two completely independent worlds either. An intimate relationship can affect how a ruler is presented publicly; a political demand can change what happens within a marriage. The screenplay makes use of this interplay. The same person must respond as a lover, husband and figure of authority, even though these positions do not allow him to demand exactly the same things.

The imperial divorce written in the text offers a concrete example. The divorce is presented through a ceremony before the court and family, with declarations that turn a couple’s decision into an official event. When Josephine cannot continue her statement and someone else completes it, her personal words become part of a procedure. The written scene makes it possible to observe a tension between the public form of the act and the cost it has for those who take part in it.

There is no need to resolve this tension by attributing a single emotion to everyone present. The organisation of a ceremony can impose an order of speaking and an appearance of continuity even when its participants hesitate. Protocol does not eliminate affection, but nor does it protect it from political needs. The analysis of power and institutions makes it possible to compare this situation with other forms of authority without equating their contexts.

Josephine’s position also changes. Reading her solely as the cause of Napoleon’s difficulties would reproduce the perspective of someone who considers themselves wronged. The text gives the characters distinct voices, conduct and circumstances, making it possible to ask another question: how much room does each character have to negotiate a relationship shaped by unequal power? The answer does not require idealising either of them or turning the dramatic portrayal into a historical verdict on their entire lives.

What can be analysed in a relationship that was never filmed

The screenplay retains encounters after the separation, including those set in Malmaison. Their dramatic interest lies in the fact that the institutional change in the relationship does not immediately erase its emotional history. The conditions of access, forms of interaction and public standing change, while memories and expectations persist. A civil status can be established through an act; shared experience is not reorganised so quickly.

This difference offers a point of connection with desire and jealousy in other Kubrick works, but the type of evidence must be kept in mind. In a completed film, we can study a silence, a look and its duration. In Napoleon, we examine the words and directions in a document. A written pause opens up possibilities for interpretation; it does not determine an actor’s voice, the camera distance or the timing an editor would have chosen.

The same applies to settings and costumes. A room, a ceremony or a visit can socially position the characters, but the text’s directions are not enough to reconstruct a definitive staging. The design materials for the project are another source and must be related to the text with care. Not every preparatory image corresponds to a specific scene, and not every written scene has a surviving visual solution.

The relationship can be read as a conflict between the capacity to act and the capacity to gain recognition. Napoleon has public instruments that do not guarantee intimate consent; Josephine takes part in a relationship whose effects extend beyond the private sphere. This is an interpretation of the dramatic construction, not a documented statement of the director’s intentions. It allows for other readings that give greater weight to dependence, social representation or the couple’s changing position.

The historical documentation assembled for Napoleon makes it possible to investigate where certain episodes came from, but it does not make the transition from history to screenplay transparent. Selection, abridgement and juxtaposition already alter a relationship. The interest of these written characters lies precisely in this arrangement: the intimate bond introduces uncertainty where public power seems to promise control, without either sphere fully explaining the other.

References: Stanley Kubrick, Napoleon, screenplay dated 29 September 1969, sequences on correspondence, marriage, imperial divorce and Malmaison. University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, Napoleon section, SK/18/1. The interpretations refer to the written document and do not presuppose a completed staging.

View all articles in Kubrick’s Napoleon: development of an unrealised project