Researching Napoleon: index cards, images and historical advice

Researching Napoleon involved more than simply accumulating books. The surviving materials show an effort to organize events, connect people and turn historical documentation into useful questions for a film.

A timeline makes it possible to compare what is happening at the same time

The Stanley Kubrick exhibition catalogue reproduces the project’s chronological index. Its caption explains that students associated with historian Felix Markham organized events from Napoleon’s life and that coloured tabs distinguished people. The photograph offers a view of the physical organization of research, not the full contents of every card. That distinction defines what can be claimed on the basis of the reproduction available.

The usefulness of a system like this does not depend solely on preserving dates. A biography read from beginning to end presents a sequence; an index allows you to return to a moment and connect it with several people’s trajectories. For screenwriting, that possibility helps raise questions about which people could have met, what information was available or how much time separated two decisions. These are organizational questions that a continuous narrative may leave scattered across chapters far apart.

The tabs make selective retrieval easier. Their function should not be confused with a complete interpretation of events: identifying a person does not explain why they acted in a particular way. The physical arrangement offers an entry point to the documentation. It is still necessary to assess the content of the sources, their discrepancies and the degree of certainty attached to each fact. Classification makes information searchable without automatically turning it into a definitive version of history.

The Kubrick archive and its types of documents make it possible to put that distinction in context. A research index, a screenplay and a production letter can be related, but they address different questions. The first organizes references; the second proposes a narrative; the third may record an administrative matter or a decision. Reading them as if they were interchangeable evidence would obscure precisely the division of labour that their preservation allows us to study.

Markham: consulting an interpretation, not receiving a finished film

UAL’s catalogue SK/18/1 identifies conversations with Felix Markham among the project materials. The TASCHEN edition’s presentation also announces transcripts of those conversations. These references establish that documented historical consultation took place; they do not allow us to attribute every line of the screenplay to the historian or reconstruct each conversation without consulting its contents. A specialist’s participation and the authorship of a scene are questions that require different kinds of evidence.

A consultation can help frame a question more effectively before answering it. Dating an event, assessing personal testimony and explaining a political decision do not call for the same kind of response. Preparing a film means translating those differences into problems of representation: what will be shown, what a character will be able to say and what information will have to be conveyed by other means. Historical advice provides context, but it does not eliminate the choices involved in selecting material for the writing.

Nor does a match between a historical source and a scene allow us to infer exclusive reliance on that source. A particular wording may appear in several books or documents, and research may compare different versions. Attributing a specific decision to Markham would require locating the exchange or note that establishes the connection. This caution does not diminish the importance of his collaboration; it prevents reducing a consultation process to a single explanation for everything that appears later in the text.

The Napoleon screenplay is where information becomes planned duration, dialogue and action. Documentation provides alternatives; the writing must choose and organize them. That relationship cannot be measured solely by how much information is carried over. A document may be useful because it helps rule out a scene or sharpen a question, even when none of its wording appears directly in the surviving version.

Images address different questions than dates

The project’s publications bring together visual references, costume studies and location photographs. Their diversity matters more than any total number of images. A period image, a photograph of a building and a costume proposal do not relate to the past or to filming in the same way. The first represents something through a historical perspective; the second records a place at another point in time; the third may explore a solution that has yet to be approved.

Comparing these materials requires asking where they came from and what use is attributed to them. A portrait may tell us about the public representation of a character without neutrally describing their everyday appearance. A location photograph allows us to study a space, but does not prove that filming took place there. A costume proposal documents a material possibility. Preserving these distinctions prevents every image in the archive from being treated as evidence of a decision that was carried out.

The preparation of locations and production resources requires another translation in turn. A reference may suggest a space and still present challenges involving access, scale or continuity. Historical research does not, on its own, guarantee that a cinematic solution is feasible. Its value lies in providing an organized body of knowledge and alternatives on which those decisions can be based, not in automatically anticipating their outcome.

The case makes it possible to study Kubrick’s preparation and revision method without reducing it to a label of obsession. Concrete practices can be identified: classifying events, distinguishing people, consulting a specialist and gathering images from diverse sources. Each practice addresses a need and has limits. The index makes information easier to retrieve; consultation helps assess it; visual references open up possibilities for representation. Documentary research takes on meaning through these relationships, not as an accumulation that would guarantee the future film simply by virtue of its size.

References: University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, catalogue SK/18/1, “Napoleon.” Eva-Maria Magel, “The Best Movie (N)ever Made: Stanley Kubrick’s Failed Napoleon Project,” Stanley Kubrick exhibition catalogue, pp. 156–159. TASCHEN, publisher’s presentation of Stanley Kubrick’s Napoleon, edited by Alison Castle.

View all articles in Kubrick’s Napoleon: Development of the Unmade Project