Kubrick’s Napoleon had a screenplay, location research, casting proposals and production plans. These materials allow us to assess its preparation without turning a negotiation into a completed shoot.
From the historical archive to the working locations
Preparing Napoleon in practical terms meant turning an extensive biography into workable shooting days. A palace might be attractive for its architecture but impractical because of travel, permits or lighting. A landscape suited to a campaign would not, by itself, solve the problems of accommodation, costumes or moving an army of extras. The project had to coordinate these challenges, not simply gather attractive images of Europe.
The Stanley Kubrick Archive holds a section on shooting preparation, SK/18/1/1, with documents about casting and locations. Its subdivisions include studies of Romania and places considered for the battles. The existence of these files demonstrates organised work; it does not mean that every photographed place was booked as a location. A folder may bring together alternatives that were being compared precisely because no final choice had yet been made.
It is worth distinguishing this search from the work of historians. Napoleon’s historical research provided timelines, references and questions about the characters. Location scouting had to answer a different question: where could an image be made to meet those needs? A real setting and a substitute space could compete for the same cinematic purpose, without choosing the latter meaning that all historical requirements had been abandoned.
The production proposal did not remain fixed, either. A memo from October 1971 proposed separating small interiors, medium-scale exteriors and large troop movements. This phased approach helps show how far the planning had progressed. It also shows that the work was still being reorganised after the initial financing difficulties, rather than following a single schedule that had been set once and for all.
A proposed cast is not the same as a cast that performed
The names associated with the project relate to different circumstances. In his 2019 interview with Lynsey Ford for Cineaste, Jan Harlan recalled David Hemmings as the choice for Napoleon, with an agreement conditional on the production going ahead. Harlan placed discussions about Jack Nicholson at a later stage. These were not two actors who replaced one another during filming: filming never took place.
Audrey Hepburn’s letter, held as SK/18/1/1/1/1 and dated 17 November 1968, provides a different kind of evidence. The actor declined to take part because she wanted to stay away from work at the time. The catalogue identifies the role as probably Josephine. That distinction matters: there is a documented response, while the identification of the character retains the caution of the archival description.
A declined offer should not be included in a cast list as if it had led to a performance. Nor does an actor’s expressed interest prove an unconditional engagement. Availability, financing, dates and acceptance of the terms could all still be undecided. This distinction is particularly important when popular lists bring together names from different years under a single image of the supposed final cast.
Retrospective accounts add information that may not appear in an individual letter, but they have their own perspective. Harlan was involved in organising the project and explained the plans from that experience. His recollection can be clearly attributed without treating it as a surviving contract. The collaboration between Kubrick and Jan Harlan helps place that coordinating role in context, distinct from the artistic decision-making about each character.
The scale depended on how the film was organised
The 1971 memo envisaged contracts that would allow the actors’ work to be divided into stages. This affected the project as a whole: if actors had to return after a break, their availability would shape the schedule and could alter the budget. Finding a suitable lead was not enough. The working arrangements had to fit a film spread across different locations, seasons and requirements.
The planned armies introduced another level of organisation. Published accounts and recollections of the project give different figures for soldiers and horses. Repeating one of them as the definitive complement would conceal that variation. What the documents usefully establish is that support was being sought for large gatherings of people and that Romania featured in those plans; they do not establish that a particular number of people worked in front of Kubrick’s cameras.
The difference between capacity being offered and resources being available also applies to costumes. A proposal could estimate clothing for large groups without all those costumes having been made. Uniform studies and tests helped assess appearance and cost, but their existence does not certify that a complete order was fulfilled. The process advanced through partial decisions that depended on one another.
Preparation should not be measured only by what was missing. A phased programme, an actor’s response and a location file are concrete results of the preliminary work. Each answers a different question: how to schedule filming, who was available and which spaces could be used. Together, they describe a production studied in detail, although they do not prove that every version was just days away from starting.
The story of Napoleon’s cancellation explains why this organisation did not become a film. To compare the project with a historical production that did make it to filming, the production of Barry Lyndon offers a different case. Its actual decisions should not be retrospectively applied to Napoleon: a shared research background does not erase the gap between planning a shoot and carrying it out on location.
References: University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, SK/18/1/1 and SK/18/1/1/1/1. Jan Harlan, interview by Lynsey Ford, Stanley Kubrick’s Napoleon, The Greatest Movie Never Made, Cineaste, autumn 2019. Stanley Kubrick, memo dated 20 October 1971, reproduced in Eva-Maria Magel’s study of the project for the Stanley Kubrick exhibition catalogue.
View all articles in Kubrick’s Napoleon: development of an unrealised project
